34 Comments
Comment deleted
Expand full comment

Shouldn’t it be Santa Barbie-ra?

I’m sorry, I’ll show myself out.

Expand full comment
author

We haven't had to suspend anyone's accounts yet, but...

Expand full comment
Jul 23, 2023Liked by Scott Tobias

Sorry to be the “actually” guy, but that scene takes place on the Venice boardwalk (and that’s the Venice police station). There is mention of Santa Monica, which is coastal and adjacent, but Santa Barbara is 100 miles north of LA.

Expand full comment
author

A year or two in California and already an expert. Damn.

Expand full comment

Ha, let’s not get carried away. Meanwhile we went to the Valley this morning to see a screening in Burbank, and you can bet I called it BARBank. (My wife’s underwhelmed, Baumbachian reaction: “Barbie gets a rethink, and Chantal Akerman is dead.”)

Expand full comment
Jul 20, 2023·edited Jul 20, 2023

I wasn’t as enamored of Oppenheimer as Keith is -- and I did see it in 70mm IMAX, which means it was under the best possible circumstances -- largely because I felt the Strauss confirmation hearing was probably one layer too many.

Last night I watched Roland Joffé’s Fat Man and Little Boy to see how it treated the same story. As expected, it’s much more linear, and even provides the viewer with multiple scenes of Oppenheimer being actively involved in the science behind the development of the bomb. In Nolan’s film, we’re expected to take it on faith that he’s so brilliant because he knows so many other brilliant scientists (Einstein, Bohr, Heisenberg, etc.) and everyone else keeps mentioning how brilliant he is.

Expand full comment

Though the actor who plays Oppenheimer in FMALB has so little presence it's truly startling.

Expand full comment

Reading about the fluid time-jumping of Oppenheimer reminds me of the finest chapter in the Watchmen graphic novel, the one with Dr. Manhattan on Mars. I can't even remember if that chapter is depicted at all in the awful movie...sounds like Nolan does a better job here, thankfully.

As far as Barbie goes...I almost feel like I've seen this movie five times. Certainly the marketing machine is set to 11.

Expand full comment
author

Oh, that’s a good point of comparison.

Expand full comment

Went to a BARBIE pre screening party/movie event last night. Film def tries juggling a myriad of messages, trying to please many masters. May not have been perfect, but the absolutely full theatre (first time for me since pre-pandemic seeing that) had a blast (although a number of jokes blew well over their heads, like a throwaway Proust joke)

Expand full comment

I want to read this so bad, but I’m going to wait until after tomorrow.

I have tickets for Oppenheimer at the IMAX, and Barbie at the local arthouse.

My husband is taking the day off work so we can go together.

I haven’t been this excited for a movie release date in years.

Expand full comment

I actually see Oppenheimer on Sunday (70mm!) but every time I see Cillian Murphy in the previews I want him to be cast as a younger Christopher Walken in a biopic.

Expand full comment
author

I'm so desperate to see Oppenheimer in 70mm IMAX, but I'd have to drive from Chicago to Indianapolis to do it.

Expand full comment

I get 70mm, no IMAX — pretty much an either/or for me in Portland, and I'd rather give my money to the Hollywood than Regal.

Expand full comment
Jul 20, 2023Liked by Scott Tobias

It’s a hike, to be sure, but the IMAX screen at the Indiana State Museum is awe-inspiring.

Expand full comment
founding

Chicago doesn't have it??

Expand full comment
author

We have a 70mm print at Music Box, which is great, but our IMAX theater was shut down. It was at Navy Pier. I remember seeing the press screening of Nolan's The Dark Knight there, which was only partially shot in IMAX format and that was fun. You'd get a 2:35-1 ratio for much of the film and during certain sequences, screen-filling IMAX. Given how obviously Chicago the film's Gotham City is, it was a good time.

That said, I don't believe the Navy Pier IMAX ever projected on film. I could be wrong about that.

Expand full comment
Jul 21, 2023Liked by Scott Tobias

I’m almost 100% sure Interstellar was shown in 70mm IMAX film at Navy Pier.

Expand full comment
Jul 22, 2023Liked by Scott Tobias

Oddly enough, the one movie I saw at that IMAX was BATMAN BEGINS.

About to see it in 70mm--the IMAX 70mm release in DC got canceled (damn the Smithsonian for still not having the Air and Space IMAX in DC proper open) so this will be the next best thing

Expand full comment
author

Hell yeah. See you on the other side.

Expand full comment

Just looked it up because I was curious and for 70mm IMAX I'd have to drive to either Langley, BC or Sacramento from Portland.

Expand full comment

I have also been thinking about Twin Peaks: The Return in the lead up to Oppenheimer! And last week I realized that Ruth De Jong is the production designer for Oppenheimer! (She was also the production designer for Twin Peaks: The Return - I have her name memorized from seeing it in the opening credits so many times.)

Expand full comment

S/o to Keith for being the only reviewer I e seen mention that millennial icons Olivia Thirlby and Michael Angarano are in this 😂

Expand full comment
founding

got this emailed to me today "Experience Oppenheimer in IMAX 70mm Film, the way Director Christopher Nolan intended!"

are senate hearings really improved in IMAX?

Expand full comment

I doubt it. It reminds me of how everyone was gushing over Tarantino filming The Hateful Eight in 70mm and...dude...whole thing takes place inside a cabin. Who gives a shit?

Expand full comment

My local cinema will either let me see Oppenheimer at 6pm (smack in the middle of getting small children ready for bed) or 10pm (which will end at 1:30am, 4.5 hours before small children get out of bed). Genuinely contemplating taking a half day off work to go further afield.

Expand full comment

I hear you. Luckily mine had a 3:40 showing

Expand full comment
founding

Keith, what's your take on Oppenheimer's portrayal of Kitty? We get some glimpses of how she was suffering, but for me she did not seem to exist for any reason other than to serve the main character's story. There was almost nothing about who she was or what she wanted to do with her life. My main frustration with the film was that you could extend that description to almost all of the other characters except for Strauss.

Expand full comment
author

I get that. I think having Blunt play the role goes a long way, though and that the narrow focus is by design, whether that’s fair to the others or to history. I also think the line “We’ve walked through fire together” (or whatever the exact quote is) says more about their marriage than the usual biopic moment with yelling and smashed plates.

Expand full comment

Perhaps this is Barbie-influenced Gosling brain speaking, but I think Oppenheimer would make an interesting double feature with First Man - I feel like Chazelle accomplished something similar in creating a kinetic, visceral and somewhat iconoclastic/avant garde/experimental experience out of the historical biopic structure and within the major studio system.

I don’t really know if that movie’s left much of a cultural or critical impression (maybe it’s too much in the shadow of the Right Stuff - which could work too!) but I love it.

Expand full comment

Just wanted to mention that Barbie’s design was based on that of a German sex doll named Lilli. Was THAT addressed in the film?

Expand full comment
author

I would never spoil such a thing.

Expand full comment

Enjoyed Barbie a lot and think Scott is spot on in his review, although I rated it a bit higher just because I found the Ken stuff so funny. Second act is a little weak (the real world) but it bounces back so strongly in the third.

What I think the culture war surrounding it (from seemingly both conservatives and leftists) misses is that any political statement Barbie is making is functionally the same as venting. It is not seriously arguing that men should be relegated to Ken status at the end of the film, it’s just giving women a fun time to let their frustrations escape through.

But man, those tv screens with horse footage on a loop - I laughed so hard at that. That’s all I really needed

Expand full comment